Why Scandal’s abortion story was so remarkable

pope

Spoilers ahead for the mid-season finale of Scandal.

Our popular culture is light years behind reality when it comes to depicting women’s reproductive choices. Even though 1 in 3 women will have an abortion before the age of 45, the subject is rarely portrayed on TV. In the rare times there is an abortion story, it’s usually fraught and sometimes tragic (although in real life 95% of women don’t regret their abortions), or a convenient miscarriage happens so viewers never have to cope with a woman making the decision to terminate a pregnancy.

There have been exceptions to the rule, but Shonda Rhimes took a major step for network television with an abortion story on Scandal that was remarkable in a number of ways:

  • The scene actually showed Olivia Pope undergoing the procedure. Last week’s episode was the first time an abortion procedure was shown on network television. As Sarah Kliff writes at Vox, “More commonly, television shows with abortion storylines will often use shots of women in abortion clinic waiting rooms or in bed after the procedure as a way to indicate what happened.” Lenika Cruz describes the scene: “The camera didn’t ogle, but it didn’t shy away from Olivia’s wide-eyed gaze either. The message? This is normal. This is acceptable. This is Olivia’s choice, and hers alone.”
  • The abortion was portrayed without handwringing (or any discussion at all). Olivia is watching the news and we suddenly realize the scene is taking place in a clinic waiting room. The abortion takes place in a scene without dialogue, and we never see Olivia weighing her options and displaying the doubts and guilt often associated with abortion on TV. While I imagine this isn’t the last we’ll hear of Olivia’s decision, it was one she made by herself and executed without the drama and tension we usually see.
  • The character having an abortion has the means to raise a child. As Kliff points out, “Most abortion storylines on television involve people who would struggle to take care of a newborn baby — often teenagers who plan to complete high school or go to college and have a whole career ahead of them.” In this case, Olivia has the financial resources, but chooses not to have a child. As the rest of the episode shows, she was in the midst of a toxic relationship, and she made the decision she felt was best for herself.
  • Olivia doesn’t face tragic consequences after undergoing an abortion. Of course we haven’t seen how this entire storyline will play out, and just about anything can happen on Scandal. But in a cultural environment in which characters who have, or think of having, abortions often die (despite it’s being one of the safest medical procedures), it’s refreshing to see it portrayed in a straightforward way. Given the way Rhimes has handled other feminist plot lines, there’s good reason to trust her with this one.
  • The abortion story takes place in the context of an episode about reproductive rights as human rights. As icing on the cake of an already groundbreaking plot line, this episode of Scandal prominently featured Mellie Grant defending Planned Parenthood in the Senate. Rhimes created a feminist fantasyland in which a female Republican senator would filibuster a budget bill that merely threatened Planned Parenthood’s funding. In a Wendy Davis-like marathon speech, Mellie points out the other government funding programs the Senate takes for granted and highlights the ridiculousness of even having to fight for basic women’s healthcare.

Of course there has been backlash to the episode. Lenika Cruz notes that some Twitter users condemned Rhimes for injecting her beliefs into the show. First of all, I’m all in favor of showrunners injecting their feminist beliefs into shows. But the fact is that she just frankly portrayed a very common event in women’s lives, and I hope more people will follow her lead.

 

 

Advertisements

Author: Rebecca Griffin

I am a passionate advocate for progressive causes with over a decade of experience organizing for social change. That organizing experience informs the way I look at the world and the challenges we face in working toward social justice. I started Of Means and Ends to write about social issues I care about and share my thoughts on how we organize in a smart, strategic way. Please visit and join the conversation.

3 thoughts on “Why Scandal’s abortion story was so remarkable”

  1. I was very impressed with this entire episode for all the reasons you stated and even more: not all women are feminists, not all women support each other, not all women appreciate feminism or understand its goals, and not all women (even smart, politically savvy women) understand the way being ant-feminist works against themselves. Well done, writers and Shonda Rhimes.

    One bone to pick: as someone who has had that type of vacuum aspiration abortion (and I bet $100 that both Kerry Washington and the director have NOT), the actress/character was showing a woman who was feeling much too physically “fine” immediately afterwards.

    Gotta say: abortions HURT. We are sore afterwards. We bleed. A lot. We need to lie down. We need to rest. We need to push fluids. We are not “fine.” We have just had a serious medical procedure that, even if we are psychologically “fine,” takes its toll on our bodies.

    Olivia Pope should have been more debilitated physically by the procedure during her talk with the President. She should have been sitting down more. She should have been more tired. She should have been less willing or able to argue or even talk a lot.

    That’s all.

    Best to you all,

    Sally Ember, Ed.D., life-long feminist and proud of it

    Like

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s